Nickie Evans


Nickie Evans

Nickie Evans

Phone: M: 614.832.1314 614.832.1314 mobile
Phone: O: 614.451.0808 614.451.0808 office
Office: Coldwell Banker King Thompson
3160 Kingsdale Ctr
Upper Arlington, OH 43221-2000

Nickie Evans is a full-time agent passionate about helping people with their most valuable asset, their home. She believes that successful business relationships are based on dedication, communication, performance, and an ongoing commitment.

Her skills as a transaction manager help make the buying and selling process as easy as possible for her clients. However, it is Nickie’s negotiation skills that give her clients unparalleled confidence. By pairing with Coldwell Banker King Thompson, Nickie has access to state-of-the-art marketing tools, technology, and the strongest online presence in the industry. Nickie capitalizes on these tools with the use of professional photos and well-written descriptions.

Whether buying or selling, Nickie consistently exceeds her clients’ expectations by providing sound and current market information – truly setting her apart from the others.

Nickie has a Bachelor of Arts in Education and a Master of Science in Economics, both from Ohio University. She and her husband, Chuck, are big fans of the OU Bobcats.

Originally from Bryan, Ohio, a small town in the Northwest corner of the state, Nickie is proud to call Columbus home. She is passionate about the unique, diverse neighborhoods within the City and throughout the surrounding suburbs. Since moving to Columbus in 2000, Nickie has lived in many areas of the city: Victorian Village, German Village, Marian Village, Hilliard, Lewis Center, and Dublin. She and her husband currently live in Grandview Heights with their three children and Saint Bernard, Frank.

Nickie enjoys reading, camping, hiking, cooking and spending time with family. She is also the head coach of a Girls on the Run group and she is active in the Parent Teacher Organization at her children’s schools.




"Nickie understood our needs and wants. She helped us every step of the way and kept us focused on our endgoal. Loved working with Nickie!"

  -Jaclyn Nelson (Buyer), Client

"Nickie Evans made an extremely diffucult decision in life very comfortable and emotionally wonderful for my mother. The buyers she shared the property with are wonderful. Great fit for neighborhood!"

  -Denise Larson, Grandview Hts Oh (Seller), Client

"Nickie Evans is very knowledgeable, super responsive and will work hard for you."

  -Laura Allen (Buyer), Client

"Nickie was excellent! We really value her expertise and her hard work on our behalf."

  -Joel & Kate, Clintonville (Seller), Client

"Nickie was a real pleasure to work with and I have to admit we weren't the easiest clients, having a house requirement list about a mile long. Nickie took all of our needs into consideration and showed us everything that came on the market with those requirements for over two years (talk about perseverance!). After much searching, she introduced us to our perfect house and did everything to make sure the deal went smoothly. She is easy to work with, professional and motivated for her clients. I would definitely recommend Nickie!"

  -Marissa Simon, Grandview (Buyer), Client

"My husband and I cannot imagine our home buying process without Nickie's caring, up beat attitude. Nickie's range of knowledge, from whole neighborhoods to little details, put us at ease. As a couple with non flexible schedules, Nickie was above accommodating. As first time home buyers, we had many questions and concerns about the process. Nickie carefully walked us through each step and always made sure we were comfortable. Nickie's persistence and patient helped us find the perfect home."

  -Natalie Crabtree, Westerville (Buyer), Client

"Wow! 5/5 Satisfaction, Performance, Recommendation. "

  -Jim Rhone Grove City (Buyer), Client

"Nickie Evans was a delight to work with and we really felt like she had our best interests at heart. She was spot on with all aspects of the sale, and our home sold very quickly and easily."

  -Lisa S., Columbus (Seller), Client

"Nickie treated us like people, not clients. She is warm and personal and enthusiastic about her work. She knew the names of our kids AND our pets before our second meeting! Fantastic working and professional experience. Nickie is an ace!"

  -Tim Leet, Columbus (Seller), Client

"Nickie did a great job and I would not hesitate to recommend her to others."

  -Norb - Arlington (Buyer), Client

"As first time sellers, my husband and I were pretty unsure of what to expect in the house selling process. Nickie was extremely patient with us and guided us through the process. She was very approachable and easy to contact at any time of day via email, phone, or text. We would recommend Nickie to friends and family. "

  -Stephanie, Columbus (Seller), Client

"We had been looking for homes on and off for over a year. We got outbid on at least 6 properties. We are first time home buyers but did not have unrealistic expectations. Before working with Nickie Evans, we were working with a realtor that did not have our best interest in mind. He just kept blaming the strong market for why we were not getting a house. Then at the start of 2016, I contacted Nickie, who I had known previously but never worked with on a realty capacity. She was professional, kind and enthusiastic. We met in a coffee shop to discuss budget, what I was looking for, and strategy. I took home some properties that currently fit the criteria and then were in correspondence about other properties as they went on the market. Through the whole process, Nickie was so helpful and continued to advocate for us. I would recommend her to anyone who is searching for a house and especially others like us, a young couple looking to live in an urban area."

  -Katie Seringer, Columbus OH (Buyer), Client

"Nickie Evans is the best!"

  -Paul Webb, Dublin (Seller), Client

"She is both friendly and professional. She earned my trust immediately and I always felt she represented me and my interests well when dealing with potential buyers' agents. I have told numerous people that if they are considering selling their home, they would be foolish to use anybody other than Nickie Evans. From day one until I signed the papers at closing, I have felt she has had my best interests in mind. I know the expertise and strategies she's honed allowed me to have the best possible experience in selling my home. I can't wait to use her as my buying agent. I'm confident she will find me the perfect home."

  -ZillowUser6659621, Client

"Nickie has a stellar reputation in Grandview Heights. She knows the neighborhood and the people who live here. I know she has helped other neighbors successfully sell and buy Grandview homes. She was the only person I wanted to handle such an important transaction. After working with her, and talking with her about purchasing a new home in the future, I learned that she is knowledgeable about the housing markets of many Columbus neighborhoods. She is very impressive. As a first time seller, I didn't know what to expect in the home sale process. From the very first meeting with Nickie, I was confident that I had made the right choice in asking her to be my agent. She explained every aspect of the process in clear language and explained all my options so that I could make the best, most informed decision about the sale of my home. Nickie made herself available to me in multiple ways. I texted, emailed, and called her with questions many times throughout the home sale process."

  -ZillowUser, Client

"Nickie is awesome. She has excellent skills when it comes to working with all kinds of people. She has great intuition when it comes to negotiations and a relentless positive attitude. She helped us achieve our dreams!! We got our house after navigating all kinds of hurdles. Thanks Nickie!!! Couldn't have done it without you!!"

  -Zillowuser9470993, Client

Recent Sales

Featured picture for the property 218021076
Columbus, OH
Featured picture for the property 218013352
Columbus, OH
Featured picture for the property 218042275
Bexley, OH
Featured picture for the property 216036864
Upper Arlington, OH